english / close reading

Prelude to Water Melody: How Long Has the Bright Moon Been There?

On a moonlit night, Su Shi asks questions that move between heaven and earth. The poem begins with uncertainty and ends with a wish that distance cannot defeat.

蘇軾 宋 水调歌头 · 明月几时有,把酒问青

Original text

水调歌头 · 明月几时有,把酒问青 original text

明月几时有,把酒问青天。不知天上宫阙,今夕是何年。我欲乘风归去,又恐琼楼玉宇,高处不胜寒。起舞弄清影,何似在人间。转朱阁,低绮户,照无眠。不应有恨,何事长向别时圆。人有悲欢离合,月有阴晴圆缺,此事古难全。但愿人长久,千里共婵娟。

Translation 01 / literal gloss

Stay close to the sentence.

When did the bright moon exist? Holding the wine, I ask the blue sky.

I do not know what palace in heaven, what year it is tonight.

I want to ride the wind and return there, yet fear the jade towers and halls are too cold at the height.

I rise and dance, playing with my clear shadow; how is it like being in the human world?

It turns around the vermilion tower, lowers through carved windows, shining on the sleepless.

It should not have regret, so why does it become full when people part?

People have joy and sorrow, meeting and separation; the moon has dimness and brightness, waxing and waning. This has always been difficult to make complete.

May we all live long, and share this moonlight across a thousand miles.

Translation 02 / natural English

Let the image breathe.

How long has the bright moon been there? I raise my wine and ask the blue sky.

I cannot know which heavenly palace holds this night, or what year it is.

I would ride the wind home, but I fear the jade towers would be too cold above.

I rise and dance with my clear shadow. Is this really the human world?

The moon crosses the red tower, slips through carved windows, and shines on the sleepless.

It has no reason to be bitter, so why is it roundest when people must part?

People meet joy and sorrow, come together and separate. The moon waxes and wanes. Nothing has ever been complete.

May we live long, and share this beautiful moon a thousand miles apart.

Context

What to know

The lyric is written as a moonlit meditation on separation and reunion. Rather than solve the tension between the heavenly and human worlds, Su Shi lets the poem move through doubt, imagination, and finally a generous acceptance of what cannot be made whole.

Imagery / themes

What to notice

The moon is both distant object and intimate presence. It passes over towers and windows, connecting sleepers who cannot share the same room. The closing wish turns private longing into a form of companionship across distance.

Vocabulary

Three useful phrases.

青天
the blue or clear sky, addressed as if it could answer
瓊樓玉宇
imagined jade towers and palaces in the moonlit heavens
嬋娟
beautiful moonlight or the moon’s graceful beauty

Continue reading

All English guides